How To Choose The

Best Duffle Bag

The minimalist's guide to selecting a travel duffle bag that works for you—from long term travel to weekend adventures to everyday carry.

01 Introduction

There’s more to the modest duffle bag than you may think.

How to Choose the Best Duffle Bag for Travel and Beyond

Ahh, the modest duffle bag. Evoking images of business folks walking down cobblestone streets discussing literature and debating the ideal level of tannins in wine…Or, maybe, gym rats, military personal, or rugged outdoor enthusiasts.

Whatever image duffle bags bring to mind, there’s no question that they’re a staple of the travel world. Their versatility, packability, and overall simplicity have endured the test of time. Seriously, some say duffles have been used since the 17th century (!).

Topo Designs Classic Duffel In Essex, England
Topo Designs Classic Duffel In Essex, England

But the duffle (also spelled duffel) is so much more than it used to be. Today, you can choose from massive duffles, waterproof duffles, duffles with wheels, duffles with backpack straps, laptop duffles, weekender duffles…In a world with so many options, how are you supposed to choose the right one? It’s easy to get lost in the duffle shuffle.

First of all, take a deep breath. That’s right. And another one.

Now read this guide.

We firmly believe that no one duffle will work for everyone. That’s why we’ve taken the time to write this entire guide—so you can find the duffle bag that works for YOU.

Of course, you may not have time to read this guide from start to finish. You have work to get done and shows to binge. We get it.

So, with the caveat, you can check out our top-rated duffle bags for travel below.

Reviews: Our Highest-Rated Duffle Bags

See all reviews: Duffle Bags

What You Can Expect From This Guide

Testing and reviewing gear is our modus operandi here at Pack Hacker. Our team of world travelers and gearheads have tested and reviewed hundreds of different types of travel-focused gear.

For this guide, we have gotten our hands on over 50 duffle bags and have been putting them to the test for months. We’ve used them for the daily grind and travel—some we’ve even tested on domestic and transatlantic flights.

Video Overview: How To Choose The Best Duffle Bag for Travel

Feel free to watch this guide overview in video format. We’ll go more in-depth in the written content and keep this page up to date.

Be sure to subscribe to Pack Hacker on YouTube and never miss a video.

And now, we’re going to help you choose the best duffle bag for your situation. We’re going to break down the most popular styles of duffle, sharing what we like and dislike, and what to look for and what to avoid. We’ll discuss the considerations you should make before you buy, and we’ll recommend solid options for each category (tried and tested by us, of course).

Peak Design Travel Duffel in Detroit
Peak Design Travel Duffel in Detroit, Michigan

Remember, what works well for some people will be not-so-great for others. Who knows, maybe your future favorite duffle bag hasn’t cracked our top ten. So, if you have the time, we highly suggest reading on (and not only because there are some hilarious jokes ahead of you).

Why a Duffle Bag?

Tom Bihn Aeronaut 45 Briefcase Mode
Tom Bihn Aeronaut 45 In Detroit, Michigan

These days, there are so many ways to haul your stuff—roller luggage, backpacks, messenger bags, duffles, and bags that are some combination of all of the above. So why choose a duffle bag?

Duffles Are Ideal For Two Bag Travel

As you may have guessed, two bag travel is traveling with two bags. It can play out in a few different ways—a backpack and duffle, duffle and roller luggage, or duffle and duffle. (Really, it doesn’t need to involve a duffle at all, but this is a duffle bag guide so we’re going to ignore all those other possibilities.)

Essentially, you shove your clothes and other gear into the larger bag (usually the duffle) and your laptop and other “daily essential” items into the smaller one (like a daypack).

Two Bag Travel With The Peak Design Travel Duffel & Everyday Backpack 20L
Two Bag Travel With The Peak Design Travel Duffel & Everyday Backpack 20L

Some companies have designed their bags with the two bag travel system in mind, so you can pick up a duffle and backpack that complement one another. For example, the Tortuga Setout Duffle Bag is intended to be used with the Tortuga Setout Laptop Backpack.

Duffles Make Great Road Trip Bags

Duffle bags—most of them, anyway—are good at squishing. That means they’re pretty dang good at squeezing into the random nooks and crannies left over when you’ve packed your car full of everything you’ll need for an epic, worthy-of-the-big-screen road trip. You can throw them on top of each other pretty easily too. Plus, duffles can hold a lot without much fuss, so you can worry less about optimal packing and enjoy the wind in your hair (metaphorically or literally).

Duffle Bags Stacked In The Trunk Of A Car
Duffle Bags Stacked In The Trunk Of A Car

Duffles are Easy

If you have a lot of stuff and zero patience to organize said stuff, you will love a duffle bag. Simply throw all of your unfolded clothes into the main bucket, zip it all up, and you’ll be good to go.

Duffles Can Look Professional

It can feel awkward to stroll into a business meeting dressed in professional garb…wearing a backpack. Duffle bags tend to look a little more polished.

Aer Travel Duffel In Detroit, Michigan
Aer Travel Duffel In Detroit, Michigan

Of course, this isn’t always the case. Some duffle bags look way less sophisticated than some backpacks. But head-to-head—professional backpack versus professional duffle—the duffle usually wins.

Duffles Are Budget-Friendly

There are many, many exceptions to this (looking at you, Gucci), but often you can find quality, spacious duffle bags at affordable price-points.

Because You Like Duffles

You don’t have to have a specific reason for liking duffles, maybe you just like them. If so, go for it.

02 Considerations

Don’t marry the first duffle you meet.

What to Consider Before You Buy

As we said earlier, we firmly believe there is no such thing as the Perfect Travel Duffle. There are a few key considerations you should keep in mind to find the perfect travel duffle for YOU, which we discuss below. We’ll keep coming back to these considerations throughout the guide, so pay attention! (There may or may not be a quiz.)

Your Use Case

Obviously, your use case will have a massive impact on what duffle you should choose. There is no single duffle bag that will work for every occasion. Ask yourself why you want a duffle bag and what you plan to do with it before looking at any other factors. All of the other considerations play into this one.

Patagonia Black Hole Duffel Bag 40L In Detroit
Patagonia Black Hole Duffel Bag 40L In Detroit, Michigan

Examples of common use cases:

  • Weekend trips
  • Long term travel
  • Business travel
  • Beach tote
  • Gym bag
  • Everyday carry bag

Materials & Durability

Duffles tend to get thrown around a lot. Airline workers have time restrictions, so you can be sure they’re tossed around in the bottoms of planes and—be honest with yourself—you’re probably not so gentle with them either. So make sure you purchase something that’ll last.

The North Face Base Camp Duffel Handles
Pulling The North Face Base Camp Duffel Out Of A Trunk

Likewise, you will need a more durable duffle if you’re an outdoorsy/adventurous person. Durability is not as big of a concern if you just plan to take your duffle on weekend excursions to the city a few hours driving distance away.

Consider:

The Fabric

When looking at fabrics, you’ll often see a number followed by the letter D (50D, 250D, 1000D, etc). The D stands for denier, which measures the thickness and weight of fabric (okay, truth be told it’s a little more complicated than that, but that’s the gist of what you need to know).

The higher the denier within the same fabric family, usually the more durable, but also the heavier the fabric. Note that denier won’t help you much when comparing two different types of fabrics, which all have inherent strengths (nylon is stronger than polyester, for example). But it works well as a benchmark.

Nylon

Nylon
Nylon

Nylon is one of the most common synthetic fabrics—and for good reason. It manages to be soft, durable, and lightweight. These days, nylon is almost an umbrella term. Various weaves, sewing patterns, and deniers play into nylon’s overall strength, weight, abrasion-resistance, and weather-resistance.

Ballistic Nylon
Ballistic Nylon

Within the nylon family, you’ll commonly see ballistic nylon and ripstop nylon. Ballistic nylon is basically the Superman of the fabric world (The Fabric of Steel, coming soon to a theater near you). Originally developed for military body armor, it’s durable and resistant to pilling and water. But it is heavier, which is not ideal for a duffle bag since they tend to get uncomfortable at lower weights than backpacks. The tradeoff may be worth it if you have an adventurous travel style or want your duffle to last long enough to pass down to the next generation.

Rip-Stop Nylon
Rip-Stop Nylon

Ripstop nylon, on the other hand, is also a great fabric that prevents punctures from spreading into full-on tears—something exceptionally handy to have for a duffle bag. Duffles are often tossed around, jammed into random nooks and crannies, and/or dragged across floors, meaning there’s a good risk of puncturing it. Having a fabric that prevents those punctures from ruining your bag is key. Plus, ripstop is lightweight.

That said, it’s not always as robust as higher denier fabrics like 1680D Ballistic nylon. If it’s a lower denier, it may develop holes more quickly. If so, the ripstop will save those holes from spreading and ruining the duffle, but the fabric will still have holes in it. Also, it’s usually swishy, which may be a deal-breaker for you.

Polyester

Polyester
Polyester

Another popular synthetic fabric, polyester tends to be a little less durable, a little bit heavier, and a little bit cheaper than its cousin, nylon. All that to say, you’ll usually find polyester on budget duffle bags. It’s not a bad fabric, but it’s not our favorite for duffles. Especially if your travels involve asking a lot of your bag.

CORDURA® Grade Fabrics (Nylon & Polyester)

CORDURA® Nylon
CORDURA® Nylon

CORDURA® is a brand, not a fabric, but it’s worth discussing since you’ll probably see it a few times. Plus, casually mentioning CORDURA® fabrics at a party will let everyone know just how cool you are (it’s worked for us!).

Essentially, the CORDURA® label is a stamp of quality assurance that says that the nylon or polyester has come from a CORDURA®-approved mill and production line. Anything CORDURA® will have excellent abrasion-resistance and strength-to-weight ratio.

Canvas

Canvas
Canvas

Historically canvas is made from cotton, linen, or hemp and then coated in wax for waterproofing. You can currently also find nylon and polyester canvas, too. These days, canvas isn’t super common because it tends to be heavy and susceptible to aesthetic wear and tear (like scuffing).

That said, there’s something so classic about a canvas duffle. If you’re into that heritage, historical vibe, it may be worth sacrificing some comfort.

Leather

Leather
Leather

And that brings us to leather—another fabric that evokes a sense of nostalgia and sophistication. You don’t often see pure leather duffles for obvious reasons (weight, sensitivity to the elements, maintenance required), but several duffle bags have leather accents—zipper pulls, straps, logo tags, and things like that.

Leather tends to go hand-in-hand with canvas. And may be your fabric of choice if you love that heritage look. (If you try to avoid animal products, you can also find duffle bags made with vegan leather to mimic that same bespoke feel.)

Duffel Fabric

Okay, you’re not going to find duffel duffle bags pretty much anywhere, but we wanted to mention it because this coarse woolen fabric is the OG duffle bag fabric. Duffel fabric originated in Duffel, Belgium, giving the duffel (which we now commonly spell duffle) its name. Mind-blowing, right?

TPU Coated Nylon
TPU Coated Nylon

You may also run into Tarpaulin or TPE Fabric Laminate, which are swishy fabrics that tend to be coated in a layer of Polyurethane. While both can have a crinkly, plasticy feel, they’re also very weather-resistant and durable. Water-resistance is really nice to have on a duffle since you tend to set down on the ground more than backpacks (a ground that could be wet). For that reason, we’re usually big fans of duffle bags made with these fabrics.

This isn’t a comprehensive list of all of the fabrics you’ll run into while searching for The One (by which we mean your perfect duffle, obviously), but a majority of duffle bags will be made with one or multiple of the materials mentioned above.

The Zippers

Okay, it’s time for some #ZipperTalk. For being so small, zippers are super important. Imagine throwing your stuff in your duffle minutes before you need to leave for the airport when—suddenly—thunder booms and the main compartment’s zipper breaks. A broken zipper on a duffle bag isn’t as heartbreaking as on a backpack because you can still use a duffle with a broken zipper due to its placement on the top of the bag. That said, it’s still sad and inconvenient.

The North Face Base Camp Duffel Zippers
The North Face Base Camp Duffel Zippers

Look for YKK, SBS, Zoom, and Riri zippers, which are the most common and reputable brands (we’re particularly fond of YKK zippers, which have rarely let us down over years and years of testing). And be wary of unbranded zippers—we’ve had some not-so-great experiences with them.

Also, pay attention to size. Zippers are measured on a scale of one (small) to ten (large). You should be alright with #5 zippers and greater for exterior pockets on smaller duffles, while you probably want something slightly more robust on larger duffles. Smaller sizes are okay for internal pockets or less frequented ones.

WANDRD HEXAD Carryall Duffel Zippers
WANDRD HEXAD Carryall Duffel Zippers

For extra weather-protection, there are water-repellent zippers—like YKK AquaGuard® zippers—which repel water due to a polyurethane coating. You don’t need to worry about highly water-resistant zippers unless your use case (#callback) involves traveling to places known for inclement weather, boats, and/or beaches. Note that water-repellent zippers tend to be harder/stickier to zip, so if your travels don’t involve copious amounts of water, we suggest avoiding these zips. (We will discuss weather-resistant duffles in more detail in the Alternate section of this guide.)

The Hardware

Similar to zippers, you’ll be pretty disappointed if any of the hardware on your duffle bag breaks while you’re out of the country.

Topo Designs Classic Duffel Zippers And Hardware
Topo Designs Classic Duffel Hardware

Again, do your best to avoid unbranded hardware. Duraflex, YKK, Woojin, Nifco, and ITW are all good brands that should treat you well. And, when it comes to metal versus plastic hardware, we’re partial to the former. Particularly from a durability perspective. Although if you’re trying to cut ounces, plastic may be the way to go.

Interior Organization

Timbuk2 Never Check Backpack Duffel Main Compartment
Timbuk2 Never Check Backpack Duffel Main Compartment

Duffle bags run the gamut of organization. Some have zero organization, while others have a ton of pockets and compartments. Are you planning to use your duffle as more of a gear hauler, throwing your clothes and toiletries in it while organizing everything else in a backpack? Or do you want your duffle to be the only bag you need? Your answers to those questions will tell you how much organization you’ll want.

Mode of Carry

NutSac Duffel In Detroit, Michigan
Carrying The NutSac Duffel By Its Top Handles

Traditionally, duffle bags tend to have two modes of carry: briefcase style via top handles and crossbody via a shoulder strap. But some duffles only have handles. If your use case involves any amount of walking—or even standing while carrying your duffle for prolonged periods of time—you’re probably going to want a shoulder strap.

Wearing The Aer Travel Duffel Crossbody
Wearing The Aer Travel Duffel Crossbody

But not all crossbody straps are created equal. While a simple, seatbelt style of strap is okay for smaller duffle bags, padded straps are preferable. Our favorite type of shoulder strap has thick padding that spans the entire length—or at least most of the length—of the strap. Again, how much you’ll walk with your duffle plays a big factor here.

Wearing The North Face Base Camp Duffel As A Backpack In Essex England
Carrying The North Face Base Camp Duffel As A Backpack

Some duffles have backpack straps. Although these straps tend not to be as comfortable as backpack straps on an actual backpack (go figure, right?). They may be your duffle of choice if you are dead set on owning a duffle but want more versatile carry options. We’ll discuss these duffle backpack hybrids later on in this guide and their potential downsides.

Arc'teryx V80 Rolling Duffle In Detroit, Michigan
Arc’teryx V80 Rolling Duffle In Detroit, Michigan

Finally, you have the option of a rolling duffle. Once again, we’ll go into detail about rolling duffles later on. For now, just know they’re a great option if you are unable, or simply don’t want to bear the weight of your luggage on your shoulder(s).

Size & Weight

In nearly all of the categories below, you can find duffle bags that span a huge range of sizes from 6L to 150L+. You’re not going to want to take a 6L duffle on a three week trip to Egypt (or anywhere for that matter) unless you’re extremely minimalistic. To put that in perspective, we’ve tested a 6L duffle as a lunchbox. You’re also not going to need a 150L duffle unless you’re looking for a massive, massive, massive gear hauler.

Carrying The Osprey Transporter 40 As A Messenger Bag
Osprey Transporter 40 In Essex, England

For travel, we tend to use duffle bags between 30L and 45L with the occasional 50L or 55L thrown in there when we need a bag to hold a lot of gear. Just note that around 45L, you start to get out of the carry-on compliance range for domestic flights in the U.S. Of course, your mileage may vary. We’ve heard stories of folks carrying on much larger bags. And, on the flip side, international airlines often have smaller allowances and stricter regulations (for both size and weight).

As far as weight is concerned—we tend to prefer the lightest duffle bag possible that doesn’t sacrifice durability. Duffles get uncomfortable to carry at a lot lower weights than backpacks since they don’t distribute the load between both of your shoulders and hips. (That is unless you have a duffle backpack hybrid, which we’ll get into later).

Patagonia Black Hole Duffel Bag 40L Hand Carry Mode
Patagonia Black Hole Duffel Bag 40L Hand Carry Mode

At the same time, you don’t want them to be flimsy since duffles get thrown around a lot. It can be a tricky thing to balance but don’t panic. We’ll be giving you a ton of duffle bag recommendations throughout this guide that manage to walk that line.

Some questions to ask yourself:

  • Do you want to use your duffle as a carry-on? If so it’ll need to be appropriately sized.
  • How much space do you need for your stuff?
  • Will you be traveling with a duffle and a backpack, or do you need a duffle large enough to hold all of your gear?
  • How much weight can you carry?
  • What’s your body type?
  • How much will you be walking?
  • Are aliens already among us?
  • What do plants crave?

Your Budget

This goes without saying, but you should consider how much money you’re willing to spend. Here at Pack Hacker, we generally believe in the “buy nice or buy twice” motto. In the long run, it may make more financial sense to invest in a duffle that will last you a decade instead of continually needing to replace a cheaper one (if you have the money available, of course).

Pakt One In Valencia Airport
Catching A Plane With The Pakt One At Valencia Airport, Spain

That said, high cost doesn’t always mean high quality. Sometimes you’re paying for brand name or style. That’s what our reviews are for—to help you know if a duffle is worth the money.

How much you’re planning to use your duffle also comes into play here. If you’re planning to travel with your duffle bag once every other year, you won’t need to spend as much as you would if you’re planning to use your duffle every single day.

03 Classic

The duffle that started it all.

What is a Classic Duffle?

A Classic Duffle is a duffle in its simplest form. It’s the image that comes to mind when you think of a duffle—a soft-sided bag with a zippered opening down its length. The bag can be cylindrical or square, fat or skinny, or anywhere in between. And—as we alluded to earlier—these duffles come in a huge array of sizes. We suggest between 20L and 45L for carry-on travel.

NutSac Duffel In Detroit, Michigan
NutSac Duffel In Detroit, Michigan

Why Classic Duffles?

There’s something so nice about the simplicity of a Classic Duffle. You don’t have to stress about optimizing how you pack, matching the proper gear to the proper pockets for the easiest access or most comfortable carry. You toss your stuff inside the bag, tug the zipper closed, and voila—you’re packed. And if you crave organization, you can always create your own system with packing cubes and accessory pouches, not limited by the organization built into the bag.

Topo Designs Classic Duffel With Packing Cubes Inside
Topo Designs Classic Duffel With Packing Cubes Inside

More often than not, Classic Duffles can hold a lot of stuff. We think it has something to do with the viscosity of the fabric divided by the sum of the pockets—and then, of course, you carry the one…Or it might have to do with the fact that there’s usually a big ole bucket of space in the main compartment.

Simplicity also means versatility. A Classic Duffle works for road trips, beach outings, and leg days at the gym (any day at the gym, really). Of course, it also works for air travel.

You can easily use a Classic Duffle in conjunction with a backpack—organize your tech gear in your backpack and jam your duffle bag full of clothes. In the states or on longer flights, you can bring your duffle as a carry-on and backpack as a personal item. If that won’t work, you can check your duffle and bring your backpack with you on the plane.

Two Bag Travel With The Peak Design Travel Duffel & Everyday Backpack 20L
Two Bag Travel With The Peak Design Travel Duffel & Everyday Backpack 20L

And Classic Duffles do pretty well sitting in the underbelly of a plane—unlike backpacks they don’t usually have a ton of straps and buckles sticking out that can get caught on things. Plus, stacking them with roller luggage isn’t exactly secure, so airline workers tend to put them on top of hard-sided luggage—meaning they’ll be the first out of the plane (we have an inside source who has worked as an airline baggage handler).

How to Pick the Perfect Classic Duffle

Now that you know why you may like a Classic Duffle, we’ll walk you through how to find one that will meet your needs. Before we dive in, remember that, ultimately, you need to reflect on all those considerations we mentioned in the previous section. We can tell you what’s worked for us after months of testing, but you’re the expert on your situation.

Profile

We prefer Classic Duffles that have more of an oblong shape than a square one. A wider, square top isn’t very comfortable to carry—it sits farther away from your body when you hold it by its handles. And that makes for an arm workout and an awkward shuffle. The carry handles also sit further apart from one another on a wider bag, making them difficult to grab quickly.

Peak Design Travel Duffel Hand Carry
Peak Design Travel Duffel In Detroit, Michigan

Your best bet is to look for a Classic Duffle that has a circular and/or slimmer profile—and this is especially true if you have smaller hands or a smaller frame.

Straps & Handles

The best carry handles attach in the center with a snap button or velcro, forming one mega-handle that’s easy to grab and pleasant to hold. A mega-handle means you can pick up your duffle and go—without any seconds lost to floppy handles that keep falling to opposite sides (is it just us or do floppy handles seem to be taunting you on purpose? Just us, okay…).

Topo Designs Classic Duffel Handle
Topo Designs Classic Duffel Handle

Not all Classic Duffles have an additional crossbody-style strap, but we like the ones that do. Being able to carry the bag across your body or over your shoulder while waiting to board your flight or walking to the train station is invaluable. (We’ve found that most crossbody straps on duffle bags are detachable, so you can take them off when you don’t need them. No commitment necessary.)

As we said in the Considerations section, look for crossbody straps with thick padding that spans, if not the entire length, then most of the length of the strap. A thin nylon strap becomes uncomfortable to wear when the bag is fully loaded or you have to carry it for long stretches.

Topo Designs Classic Duffel In Essex England
Topo Designs Classic Duffel Comfortable & Padded Shoulder Strap

Internal Organization

We like Classic Duffles that embrace their simplicity with organization that has been designed specifically for clothes and toiletries (as opposed to tech/daily essentials). Usually, that means a couple of pockets—maybe even a couple of exterior end pockets—but nothing that majorly cuts into the space of the main compartment. If your travels involve going to the gym or traipsing along dirty trails, you’ll probably appreciate a duffle with a shoe compartment.

Topo Designs Classic Duffel Main Compartment
Topo Designs Classic Duffel Main Compartment

The Good

  • What you see is what you get (in terms of size)
  • Easy to pack and go
  • Holds a lot of stuff
  • Works well in conjunction with a backpack for two bag travel

The Bad

  • Can get uncomfortable to carry for any extended periods (especially if it’s fully packed out)
  • You’ll likely need to travel with an additional bag if you plan to bring any tech with you, including a laptop, tablet, camera, etc
  • Doesn’t protect your stuff super well—you have to be careful what you pack

Recommendations



04 Hybrid

Is it a backpack? A duffle? No, it’s a buffle!

What is a Duffle Backpack Hybrid?

A Duffle Backpack—or Hybrid Duffle, as we call them around HQ—is a pack that’s attempting to be both a backpack and a duffle (buffle? duffpack?…Definitely buffle). Most of the time, buffles skew one way or another—they’re either a backpack first or a duffle first. You can get an idea by looking at the shape of the pack and the orientation of its organization. In this guide, we’ll be focused on packs that are primarily duffle bags with backpack straps.

Carrying The North Face Base Camp Duffel As A Duffel In Essex England
The North Face Base Camp Duffel In Essex, England

Why Duffle Backpacks?

We like the idea of buffles because they’re versatile. You get the benefits of a duffle—simplicity, durability, space—while being able to carry it as a backpack when you find yourself having to walk far (i.e. the airport to your hostel, across the terminal, etc.) BUT—

We’re going to be straight with you, while buffles are increasing in popularity, we find they’re extremely difficult to do right. (As opposed to messenger bags, which are small enough they can get away with being hybrids.) Usually, these packs end up being mediocre as both a backpack and a duffle, instead of excelling at one or the other. In general, we prefer to have an exceptional backpack or an exceptional duffle bag.

WANDRD HEXAD Carryall Duffel In Essex, England
WANDRD HEXAD Carryall Duffel In Essex, England

One day a company may crack the elusive buffle (we live in a time with fancy canned wine, so anything’s possible). Until then, we recommend picking either a duffle bag or a backpack (we have a guide to help you out with that one too).

That all said, if you understand the risks, and are still dying to have a Hybrid Duffle because you hate backpacks, but walk enough you would appreciate a backpack style of carry every once and a while, we’ll walk you through what you should look for:

How to Pick the Perfect Hybrid Duffle:

Profile

Similar to a Classic Duffle, a slimmer profile is better for Hybrid Duffles. Not only because the handles are closer together for an easier carry in duffle mode, but a slimmer pack will also sit nicely against your back when converted to backpack mode.

Tom Bihn Aeronaut 45 Buckling
Tom Bihn Aeronaut 45 Buckling

Since duffle bags usually lack the structure typical for backpacks, buffles tend to slouch against your back in backpack mode. Some more so than others. If you’re planning to use your buffle in backpack mode semi-frequently, look for a pack with a bit more structure.

You can also add structure by packing strategically. We’re going to assume that you’ll be packing the bag when it’s in duffle mode (which will usually be the case for a Hybrid), but think about where your gear will end up when you wear your bag as a backpack. Pack the heavier stuff so it’s as close to your back as possible. Also, put flat items against your back to prevent anything poking into you—packing cubes are a great way to flatten out traditionally un-flat items like clothes—and keep the bag fully packed out so it retains its shape.

Straps & Handles

Buffle handles are where things can get weird. Often, the handles are supposed to work as both carry handles and backpack straps. And, often, these two-for-one handles fail at both.

WANDRD HEXAD Carryall Duffel In Essex England
WANDRD HEXAD Carryall Duffel Shoulder Straps Being Used As Duffle Handles

Look for handles that taper in at their center—this will make them easier to grab and hold. If they’re not tapered, the experience of holding the handles will be akin to carrying a backpack by its shoulder straps, which is pretty unpleasant (unless you have massive hands). You’ll also want a little bit of padding for a comfortable backpack carry.

The North Face Base Camp Duffel Shoulder Straps
The North Face Base Camp Duffel Shoulder Straps

There are some Hybrid Duffles out there that, instead of having carry handles that also act as backpack straps, have separate backpack straps that either detach or tuck into the back panel when not in use. Usually, this means that the quality of the backpack straps and handles are better. But it takes time to switch between duffle mode and backpack mode. You can’t just throw the buffle on your shoulders when the handles start to get uncomfortable.

Tom Bihn Aeronaut 45 Backpack Straps
Tom Bihn Aeronaut 45 Backpack Straps Pulled Out Of The Hideaway Harness System

What you’ll prefer comes down to your use case. If you think you’ll be continually switching between backpack and duffle mode, you’ll want handles that pull double-duty. If you think you’ll primarily be using your buffle as a duffle, with an occasional need for backpack straps, you’ll want to look for detachable/stowable backpack straps.

One final note here is that you won’t frequently find a crossbody strap on a buffle. This can get annoying, particularly on those buffles with separate backpack straps. Carrying a duffle by its handles for more than five to ten minutes (depending on your hand strength and size, as well as the weight of the bag) tends to get unpleasant. And, sometimes, you don’t have the time to stop what you’re doing and switch it into backpack mode. You’ve got flights to catch, legs to work out, and beaches to lay upon, after all.

Interior Organization

First of all, look at the orientation of the pockets. Some buffles have vertical pockets that work best in backpack mode, but most have horizontal pockets designed with the duffle carry in mind.

Timbuk2 Never Check Backpack Duffel In Backpack Mode
Timbuk2 Never Check Backpack Duffel In Backpack Mode

Problems arise when the pockets don’t have secure openings—with a zipper, buckle, velcro, or, at the very least, some elasticity. If the pockets are open, your stuff will likely fall all over the place when you’re swapping carry modes. If you thrive in chaos then this may be a plus. Otherwise, it gets old pretty quick.

Backpack-specific Considerations

It’s rare to find a Hybrid Duffle with a decent back panel. In fact, it appears that most companies don’t put much thought into it at all—which makes us appreciate those that do. If you’re planning to use your buffle as a backpack frequently, definitely pay attention to the back panel and look for one that has padding and air channels.

Tom Bihn Aeronaut 45 Back Panel
The Tom Bihn Aeronaut 45 Back Panel Has A Little Bit Of Padding But No Air Channels

Also, any pack with an interior capacity of 30L or greater should have an option for a hip belt, so all the weight doesn’t have to dump into your shoulders.

The Good

  • The spacious interior of a duffle with a backpack’s comfortable carry (at least in theory)
  • Versatile mode of carry
  • More affordable than buying both a quality backpack and a duffle

The Bad

  • Difficult to pull off—usually ends up being a mediocre backpack and a mediocre duffle bag
  • Typically, the back panel is not well-thought-out
  • The straps tend to either be good backpack straps or good carry handles, but rarely excel at both (and sometimes fail at both)

Recommendations




05 Digital

Redefining the Classic Duffle for a tech-hungry world.

What is a Digital Duffle?

We’re going to pull back the curtain for a second and let you inside the Pack Hacker headquarters. Oh-so-long ago when the team sat down with dozens of duffles, separating them into what later became the categories you’ve been reading about, we struggled with naming the style of duffle bag designed to hold your tech—laptops, tablets, camera equipment, dongles, cords, chargers, keyboards, batteries, headphones, etc.

Tortuga Setout Duffle Laptop Compartment
Tortuga Setout Duffle Laptop & Tablet Compartment

We threw around Tech Duffle but decided that described a technical duffle—you know, one with high-tech materials that looks like it belongs in the Matrix universe. Laptop Duffle seems to be the accepted term, but it feels too limiting. Classic Duffle 2.0 was also a contender at one point but wasn’t limiting enough.

So we invented the term “Digital Duffle” because these duffle bags are designed to hold all of your tech gear (not just your laptop) and because alliteration (duh).

Aer Travel Duffel Tech Organization
Aer Travel Duffel Tech Organization

A Digital Duffle has a ton of organization going on, including a compartment for your laptop. And these duffles tend to skew smaller—think carry-on sized.

They also tend to have a sophisticated aesthetic, looking almost messenger bag-esque.

Why Digital Duffles?

We’re (obviously) huge fans of backpacks here, but we’re aware of how they can come across in a business meeting. Especially one that you’ve flown halfway across the country (or world!) for. A sharp messenger bag would probably work better than a duffle for business purposes, but sometimes you’ll have to walk off the plane and into the office and you’re going to have to bring your travel bag with you.

Aer Travel Duffel In Detroit, Michigan
Aer Travel Duffel In Detroit, Michigan

But aesthetic isn’t the only reason to choose a Digital Duffle. You’ll want to opt for one if you’re using a duffle bag as the only luggage you’re traveling with—and you travel with tech. (A Classic Duffle would work for one-bag travel if you only need to pack clothes and toiletries.)

A Digital Duffle also works for two-bag travel. Use it in conjunction with rolling luggage—using the rolling luggage for your clothes and toiletries—or with a backpack, leaving your duffle and laptop in the hotel and using your backpack while out exploring the world.

How to Pick the Perfect Digital Duffle:

Profile

As always, we recommend going for a slimmer profile to achieve a comfortable carry. This can be particularly important for a Digital Duffle since you’ll likely carry it in briefcase mode semi-frequently.

Tortuga Setout Duffle Slim Profile
Tortuga Setout Duffle Slim Profile

Also, look for structure. Rigidity will help to keep your expensive tech safe and organized.

Straps & Handles

The ideal straps and handles on a Digital Duffle are the same as the ideal straps and handles on a Classic Duffle. Look for carry handles that attach in the center with a snap button or velcro, and for a crossbody strap that has plenty of padding.

Tortuga Setout Duffle Handle
Tortuga Setout Duffle Handle

Some Digital Duffles have a single, centered grab handle, which also works just fine.

Interior Organization

You’re trusting this duffle bag to hold expensive, valuable equipment, so make sure it’s worthy of that trust. Any pockets that are specifically designed for tech—like a laptop or tablet sleeve—should have plenty of padding. And a false bottom on a laptop compartment is always appreciated. (A false bottom suspends your laptop, so it won’t crash against the ground if you accidentally drop your duffle bag a little too hard.)

Pakt One Laptop Compartment
Pakt One Laptop Compartment

Also, look for lots of pockets that will hold all those random bits and bobs—dongles, chargers, or pens if you’re a little more old-fashioned.

While not technically “interior organization”—although related to it—we want to note that lockable zippers can add some great peace-of-mind, allowing you to completely secure your duffle and the valuable stuff inside of it.

The Good

  • Sophisticated aesthetic
  • Walk from the plane into a business meeting
  • Great organization if you need more than offered on a Classic Duffle

The Bad

  • Not as convenient as a backpack
  • Can get uncomfortable to carry
  • Not always available in larger sizes

Recommendations




06 Rolling

If rolling luggage and a duffle bag had a baby.

What Is A Rolling Duffle?

A Rolling Duffle is easy to define—it’s a duffle bag with wheels…so we’re done here. Let’s jump on into the next section.

Kidding, kidding. Of course, we have plenty more to say.

Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler Wheeled Duffel 110L In Detroit, Michigan
Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler Wheeled Duffel 110L In Detroit, Michigan

Almost all of the well-known duffle bag makers—Patagonia, Osprey, Eagle Creek, The North Face, Arc’teryx, and so on—offer a rolling version of their duffles. They tend to skew large, but you can find some that are carry-on approved.

Why Rolling Duffles?

Like hard-sided rolling luggage, rolling duffles are great when you can’t or don’t want to bear weight on your shoulders. At the same time, you still have all the benefits of duffle bags—a spacious interior, flexible frame, and squishability. This squishability means that, unlike hard-sided luggage, you can squish roller duffles into overhead bins, your tiny Airbnb closet, or the trunk of your rental car. They also tend to take up less space in your house whenever you’re not traveling.

Thule Subterra Wheeled Duffel In Detroit, Michigan
Thule Subterra Wheeled Duffel In Detroit, Michigan

The soft sides are also forgiving, allowing you to cram a ton of stuff or awkwardly shaped items inside the compartments.

And, usually, they still have the option for duffle carry with handles, a crossbody strap, and sometimes even backpack straps. That means you can carry or maneuver the bags over uneven/difficult terrain. You won’t have to be that person huffing and puffing as you attempt to drag your suitcase across sandy beaches or cobblestone streets. No one wants to be that person.

Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler Wheeled Duffel 110L Carried As A Backpack
Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler Wheeled Duffel 110L Carried As A Backpack

How to Pick the Perfect Rolling Duffle:

Profile

We’ve said it three times and we’ll say it again—a duffle with a streamlined body will treat you better. The bulkier the duffle the more it tends to flop about, twisting around or slumping forward as you walk. Structure helps here too, particularly on the bottom side of the bag (look for one with a frame sheet).

Arc'teryx V80 Rolling Duffle In Detroit, Michigan
Arc’teryx V80 Rolling Duffle In Detroit, Michigan

More than with other duffle styles, it’s important to consider your height here. If you’re short, you’re not going to want a duffle with a tall body, which may feel awkward or be difficult for you to maneuver. If you’re tall, you’re not going to want a duffle with a short body, which will destroy your back and ankles.

Straps & Handles

Look for a telescopic handle (those hard, elongate-able—not a word, but you know what we mean—handles you see on hard-sided rolling luggage). Wheeling around a Rolling Duffle with a handle that’s sewn to the bag is not great for everyone and basically impossible if you’re tall—the body of the bag will twist and the wheels will bite your ankles.

Thule Subterra Wheeled Duffel Handle
Thule Subterra Wheeled Duffel Handle

And, once again, consider your height. Your goal is to find a handle that hits at your waist. The more adjustable the telescopic handle, the better it will be for people of all heights.

A Rolling Duffle with those traditional duffle straps or handles is a bonus, as it allows you to carry the pack in duffle-mode those times when having wheels is not ideal—stairs, snow, sand, soil, snake sanctuaries (just trying to stick with the “s” theme).

Interior organization

This purely comes down to personal preference. You can find Rolling Duffles with a ton of organization—in the style of a Digital Duffle—or ones that are essentially one big bucket a la Classic Duffles.

Wheels

Arc'teryx V80 Rolling Duffle Wheels
Arc’teryx V80 Rolling Duffle Wheels

Make sure you pay attention to the quality and size of the wheels. Your use case matters here too. If you’re planning on using a Rolling Duffle camping or during outdoor adventures, the wheels need to be hardy enough to go over mud/dirt/trails. When we say hardy we’re talking about toughness, but also size. Larger wheels tend to do better over different types of terrain. If you’ll primarily be wheeling your duffle through the airport and from your Uber to your hotel, you don’t have to go so robust.

The Good

  • A great choice if you can’t carry weight on your shoulders
  • Easy to roll through the airport
  • Stores better than hard-sided suitcases

The Bad

  • The wheels and telescopic handle add bulk/weight
  • More difficult to navigate uneven terrain than a backpack or regular duffle—although typically easier than roller luggage to carry
  • Certain models can be difficult to wheel, particularly when not packed out, as they twist around or slump forward as you’re walking

Recommendations




07 Alternate

But wait, there’s more.

What Other Styles of Duffle are There?

So there you have it—the four most popular styles of duffle bags. But we live in an era where there are 30+ flavors of Pop-Tarts, so you know there are duffle styles that go even deeper. Styles that fill specific niches in the market.

Let’s check some of them out.

Packable

You can probably guess what a Packable Duffle is from its name. Yes, it’s packable (we knew you could guess it, you genius you). To get more specific, Packable Duffles are built with thin and lightweight materials, allowing you to compress them into tiny packages. We’re talking approximately the size of a soda can. They typically either pack into their pocket or a separate pouch.

Osprey Ultralight Stuff Duffel In Detroit, Michigan
Osprey Ultralight Stuff Duffel In Detroit, Michigan

Usually, there’s not much else going on with Packable Duffles. No fancy carry modes or organization—their primary purpose is to compress as small as possible.

Now, you’ll find that some companies advertise a duffle as packable because it has a carrying case—but if it will take up a significant amount of space in your luggage we don’t consider it a Packable Duffle.

The North Face Base Camp Duffel Compressed In Its Carry Case
The North Face Base Camp Duffel Compressed In Its Carry Case

Why Packable Duffles?

The primary function of a Packable Duffle is to be able to pack it into your main bag and use it when you need the extra space. Say you’re going on a week-long trip out of the country and you fill your main suitcase with all the clothes, toiletries, and accessories you’ll need. You can bring a Packable Duffle as a way to bring home any souvenirs you may pick up.

Matador Transit30 2.0 Compressed
Pulling The Compressed Matador Transit30 2.0 Packable Duffle Out Of A Backpack

You can also use a Packable Duffle as a smaller bag to take with you on day trips or short excursions, while you leave your larger bag back at the hotel. (But you may find that Packable Backpacks work better for this specific use case.)

Weather-Resistant

Another aptly-named style of duffle bag. These bags have been built with inclement weather in mind and will hold strong against wind, water, snow, sleet, and so on. For a duffle to be considered weather-resistant, the materials and zippers must be resistant to water. You’ll see that a lot of companies forget the latter. But zippers are important! It’s all well and good that water will roll off the fabric, but if it leaks through the zipper track your clothes/tech/whatever will still get wet.

YETI Panga 50 Dry Duffel Zippers
YETI Panga 50 Dry Duffel Zippers

Some duffles are partially weather-resistant with water-resistant fabric and one compartment that features a water-resistant zipper (commonly a laptop compartment). This is a solid design as water-resistant zippers can be sticky and cumbersome to use.

To be clear, so far we have been discussing Weather-Resistant Duffles. Not Weatherproof Duffles. And there is a huge difference. Weatherproof Duffles, which are truly impervious to water (so much so, they’re submersible), are hard to come by. Usually, Weatherproof Duffles are made with nylon and some sort of coating or laminate.

Why Weather-Resistant Duffles?

Weather-resistance adds some great peace-of-mind because, let’s face it, the weather isn’t predictable 100% of the time. This is doubly true if your travels involve backpacking through notoriously rainy countries or you live in a place that’s in a near-constant state of drizzly.

YETI Panga 50 Dry Duffel In The Water
YETI Panga 50 Dry Duffel In The Water

Weatherproof Duffles, on the other hand, are likely overkill for most people. Unless you go on wild adventures that involve heavy precipitation, boats, backcountry fly fishing, waterfalls, etc, you probably don’t need a Weatherproof Duffle. That said, you may decide to go for it anyway. Usually, these duffles are super durable as well, so they may be a good choice if you crave that robustness.

Gear Haulers

A Gear Hauler is essentially a Classic Duffle, only gigantic. There’s no exact definition for “gigantic” at least in terms of liter capacity—what some people may be able to use for years of travel, others will only be able to use for a weekend. Still, we start to think of a duffle bag as a Gear Hauler when it can’t be used as a carry-on. And because Gear Haulers do tend to be larger, you will find a number of them with wheels.

Mystery Ranch Mission Duffel 90L In Detroit, Michigan
Mystery Ranch Mission Duffel 90L In Detroit, Michigan

More so than their size, Gear Haulers are defined by their job—and that’s to haul your gear. Usually, you won’t see anything fancy. You won’t find a robust harness system or smart internal organization. Just a massive bucket to throw all your clothes, toiletries, books, rock collection, or whatever in.

Why Gear Haulers?

A Gear Hauler is great to use when you’re traveling to one place for a long time. Say you’re going to Au Pair in France of six months or study abroad in Spain for a school year. Since you’re semi-moving to that place, you don’t need the convenience of a backpack, you just need a big ole spot to throw your stuff.

Mystery Ranch Mission Duffel 90L Main Compartment
Mystery Ranch Mission Duffel 90L Main Compartment

They’re also great if you have no interest in packing light or only traveling with the essentials. If you need the space, go for it. But, remember, these duffles will get heavy. And you will have to pay for a checked bag.

Weekender

On the other end of the duffle bag spectrum from the Gear Hauler is the Weekender. Essentially a Classic Duffle—maybe with a few more pockets—but designed to work for short excursions. We would describe the aesthetic as tote-adjacent.

Lo & Sons The Catalina Deluxe In Detroit, Michigan
Lo & Sons The Catalina Deluxe In Detroit, Michigan

Why Weekenders?

If you prefer to travel with a backpack or hard-sided luggage for longer excursions, you may consider a Weekender for those short, weekend trips. A Weekender is also great for travel in conjunction with a suitcase.

You’ll also run into several Weekenders that emphasize style—managing to be both luggage and a fashion accessory.

Luxury

Luxury Duffles are, first and foremost, designed to impress. You’ll make a statement with these polished bags from high-end fashion brands like Gucci, Louis Vuitton, and Prada.

While these duffles look polished and well-made, they’re not always adventure-ready. Think about your use case and whether or not you’d rather spend your money on a pack that’ll keep up with all you throw at it. But if you’d rather choose fashion, you have plenty of options—and not all of them will break the bank. Of course, you can spend 1,000-some dollars on a Gucci bag, but you can also find quality, stylish duffles from lesser-known brands that we would also consider luxury. Brands like Ted Baker, Tumi, Longchamp, and so on.

Why Luxury Duffles?

There’s not much to say here—Luxury Duffles are usually an aesthetic choice.

08 Conclusion

Congratulations, you’re hereby pronounced a duffle bag expert.

It’s Time To Choose The Right Duffle Bag For You

So here we are—the end (anyone else kind of sad? No, just us?). We hope that during this time you’ve spent with us journeying through the world of duffles, you’ve learned enough about these humble little bags that choosing the right one for you isn’t so overwhelming any more (and maybe you had a few laughs too).

Lots Of Duffle Bags With Tom
Best Of Luck Finding Your Perfect Duffle Bag

Before you spread your wings and fly, remember there is no such thing as THE perfect duffle. Consider your use case, assess the quality and primary purpose of the duffle bag, and then pick one you like the look of. It’s as simple as that.

We’d wish you good luck, but if you’d made it this far, you honestly don’t need it.

mm
Pack Hacker